After trying to address a rudely interrupting, unhearing, unfeeling, jeering and sneering Conservative party to deliver his response to the budget today, Jeremy Corbyn called the government “uncouth” and “uncaring” in a passionate speech, with barely constrained anger at how Conservatives’ policies are creating hardship and suffering for some of our most vulnerable citizens. A Conservative had made an inappropriate and ageist comment about Corbyn’s age, while he was addressing the Conservatives’ brutal cuts to social care.
Corbyn spoke in defence of those elderly people suffering cuts in care budgets. It has been alleged that Conservative Party whip Andrew Griffiths – hiding out of sight of the Speaker’s chair – said the Labour leader should “be in a care home” himself.
Many of us have also used those words among others – uncouth and uncaring – many times over the past seven years to describe a government that laughed when hearing about people suffering because of their policies, laughed at the accounts of those suffering hardships because of the impact of the bedroom tax, laughed at the misery of those having to visit food banks. This is the same government that has stripped our public services bare, presided over falling and stagnating wages and huge hikes in the cost of living, removed lifeline support from ill and disabled people, stripping them of the means of meeting their basic needs, their independence and dignity, and savagely reducing funding to our local authorities, and essential public services such as health and social care.
As Labour MP Laura Pidcock says: “It was absolutely right to be angry at the attitude of members on the benches opposite – shouting him down when he’s talking about serious issues, like the lack of social care services as a result of massive cuts (£6 billion) to budgets. This neglect, these holes in our safety net for vulnerable people, hurt people in reality. It is not a game.”
We have seen, over the last 7 years, the Conservatives’ authoritarianism embedded in punitive policies, in a failure to observe the basic human rights of some social groups, in their lack of accountability and diffusion of responsibility for the consequences of their draconian policies, and in their lack of democratic engagement with the opposition. Hurling personal insults, sneering and shouting over critics has become normalised by the Conservatives. They don’t debate, they simply attack on a personal level. This is not the standard and quality of debate that the public expect. Yet people don’t recoil any more from what has often been dreadfully unreasonable hectoring and terribly poor decorum. But they reallty ought to.
The budget details – pretty much more of the same
Philip Hammond finally faced up to the problem of “slower growth than predicted.” What a pity he didn’t have the balls to own the REASONS for that, which are chiefly linked to the seven year long economically inept, miserly austerity programme, aimed solely at ordinary people, especially the poorest citizens, and the deluxe “incentivisation” package designed to overindulge the hoarding wealthy.
The nations’ redistributed wealth simply trickles offshore, as we have discovered.
Those of us opposing the implicit “trickle down” philosophy of the government have won this debate several times over. Yet still the Tories persist in peddling magical thinking and neoliberal mythologies. The budget is simply more of the same economic ineptitude.
The answer to failing neoliberism is apparently more neoliberalism. It’s a budget of more of the same.
The Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) has presented a rather grim picture, slashing an average of 0.7% percentage points off UK trend productivity growth each year. That means the economy will be at least 3% smaller in 2020 than previously expected, leading to the sharp growth downgrade. It’s another sign that the UK economy is weaker than we were led to believe by the bumbling government, who are not delivering the “robust” growth that policymakers have claimed.
From the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS)
The OBR has also revised up its expected mortality rate. It’s now expected that 502,000 pensioners will die each year, up from 476,000 previously.
The OBR says:
“This is consistent with life expectancy increasing less than projected since mid-2014. By 2022, the population in this age group [adults aged above the state pension age] is 1.2% lower than previously assumed.”
What this means is that our life expectancy is falling, which is shameful in a developed and wealthy nation.
Here is the response to the budget from John McDonnell, the shadow chancellor. And here is an excerpt:
“This is a ‘nothing has changed’ budget from an out-of-touch Government with no idea of the reality of people’s lives and no plan to improve them.
Philip Hammond has completely failed to recognise the scale of the emergency in our public services.
Today’s budget has found no meaningful funding for our schools still facing their first real terms funding cuts since the mid-90s and nothing even approaching the scale needed to address the crisis in our NHS or local government.”
Corbyn has also condemned Philip Hammond’s second Budget as Chancellor, saying that it demonstrates a “record of failure with a forecast of more to come”.
The Labour leader, who was not provided with an advance sight of Hammond’s Budget, criticised the Government for repeatedly pushing back its target to eliminate Britain’s deficit, now it’s not likely to be “paid down” until at least 2030. If ever. I don’t think the Conservatives care about the deficit. They are rather more interested in privatising public services, and taking money from the poorest to hand out to the wealthiest. Their policies are not practical, they are simply ideological, revealing the very worst of their own traditional prejudices.
Corbyn said that 120,000 children would spend this Christmas living in temporary accommodation, he said: “Three new pilot schemes for rough sleepers simply doesn’t cut it.
“It’s a disaster for those people sleeping on our streets, forced to beg for the money for a night shelter,” he added. “They’re looking for action now from government to give them a roof over their heads.”
Corbyn also cited cuts to police officer numbers and rising levels of in-work poverty. He also criticised the Government for failing to take action to tackle credit card debt.
He said: “Debt is being racked up because the Government is weak on those who exploit people, such as rail companies hiking up fares above inflation year on year, and water companies and energy suppliers.”
The Labour party leader also criticised the Government’s measures on housing, saying very little was mentioned about the private rented sector – even though landlords were paid £10bn in housing benefit.
“With this Government delivering the worst rate of house building since the 1920s and 250,000 fewer council homes, any commitment would be welcome,” he said.
“But we’ve been here before. The Government promised 200,000 starter homes three years ago. Not a single one has yet been built in those three years.
“We need a large scale publicly funded house-building programme, not this Government’s accounting tricks and empty promises.”
Concluding his speech, Corbyn said: “We were promised with lots of hype a revolutionary Budget, the reality is nothing has changed.
You can watch Corbyn’s speech in full here
Here is a transcript of the core parts of his speech:
Mr Deputy Speaker, this Budget has been an advertisement for just how out-of-touch this government is with the reality of people’s lives.
Pay is now lower for most people than it was in 2010 and wages are now falling again.
Economic growth in the first three quarters of this year is the lowest since 2009 and the slowest of the major economies in the G7.
It’s a record of failure with a forecast of more. Economic growth has been revised down. Productivity growth has been revised down. Business investment revised down.
People’s wages and living standards revised down. What sort of “strong economy, fit for the future” is that?
The deficit was due to be eradicated by 2015, then 2016, then 2017, then 2020 and now 2025. They’re missing their major targets but the failed and damaging policy of austerity remains.
The number of people sleeping rough has doubled since 2010 and 120,000 children will spend this Christmas in temporary accommodation. In some parts of the country life expectancy is actually starting to fall.
The last Labour government lifted a million children out of poverty. Under this government an extra 1 million children will be plunged into poverty by the end of this Parliament. 1.9 million pensioners and one in six are living in poverty – the worst rate in Western Europe.
Falling pay, slow growth, and rising poverty. This is what the Chancellor has the barefaced cheek to call a “strong economy”.
His predecessor said they would put the burden on “those with the broadest shoulders”. How has that turned out?
The poorest tenth of households will lose about 10 per cent of their income by 2022 while the richest will lose just 1 per cent.
So much for “tackling burning injustices”. This government is tossing fuel on the fire.
Personal debt levels are rising and 8.3 million people are over-indebted. If he wants to help people out of debt, he should back Labour’s policy for a Real Living Wage of £10 per hour by 2020.
And with working class young people now leaving university with £57,000 of debt – because this government trebled tuition fees – this government’s new policy to win over young people is to keep fees at £9,250.
But that is just one of a multitude of injustices presided over by this government. Another is Universal Credit, which Labour has called on ministers to pause and fix.
That’s the view of this House. It’s the verdict of those on the frontline with evidence showing food bank use increases 30 per cent where Universal Credit is rolled out.
And the benches opposite should listen to Martin’s experience, a full-time worker on the minimum wage, he says: “I get paid four weekly meaning that my pay date is different each month”, because of that, under the UC system he was paid twice in a month and deemed to have earned too much so his UC was cut off. He goes on: “This led me into rent arrears and I had to use a food bank for the first time in my life”.
This Chancellor’s solution to a failing system causing more debt; is to offer a loan. And the six week wait, with 20 per cent waiting even longer, becomes a five week wait.
This system has been run down by £3 billion cuts to Work Allowances, the two-child limit and the perverse ‘rape clause’ – and caused evictions because housing benefit isn’t paid direct to the landlord.
So I say to the Chancellor: put this broken system on hold, so it can be fixed, and keep a million more children out of poverty.
For years we have had the rhetoric of a “long-term economic plan” that never meets its targets; when what all too many are experiencing is long-term economic pain.
And the hardest hit are disabled people, single parents and women.
So it is disappointing the Chancellor did not back the campaign of my Hon Friend for Brent Central, Dawn Butler, to end period poverty.
The Conservative manifesto has now been shredded and some ministers opposite have since put forward decent proposals, several conspicuously borrowed from the Labour manifesto.
Let me tell the Chancellor, as socialists we are happy to share.
The Communities Secretary called for £50 billion of borrowing to invest in housebuilding. Presumably the Prime Minister slapped him down for wanting to “bankrupt Britain”.
The Health Secretary has said the pay cap is over but where is the money to fund a pay rise? The Chancellor hasn’t been clear today, not for NHS workers nor for our police, firefighters, teachers or teaching assistants, bin collectors, tax collectors or our armed forces personnel.
Will the Chancellor listen to Claire? She says, “My Mum works for the NHS. She goes above and beyond for her patients. Why does the government think it’s ok to under pay, over stress and underappreciate all that work?”
The NHS Chief Executive says “the budget for the NHS next year is well short of what is currently needed”.
The Health Secretary said in 2015 he would fund another 5,000 GPs, but in the last year we have 1,200 fewer GPs. We’ve lost community nurses. We’ve lost mental health nurses.
The Chancellor promised £10 billion in 2015 but delivered only £4.5 billion so we’ll wait for the small print on today’s announcement. It certainly falls well short of the £6 billion Labour would have delivered.
Over a million of our elderly aren’t receiving the care they need. Over £6 billion will have been cut from social care budgets by March next year.
Our schools will be 5 per cent worse off by 2019 despite the Conservative manifesto promising that no school would be worse off.
5,000 head teachers from 25 counties wrote to the Chancellor, saying “we are simply asking for the money that is being taken out of the system to be returned”.
Robert wrote to me saying, “As a senior science technician my pay has been reduced by over 30 per cent. I’ve seen massive cuts at my school. Good teachers and support staff leave“.
According to this government, 5,000 head teachers are wrong. Robert is wrong. The IFS is wrong.
Councils are warning that services for vulnerable children are under more demand than ever, yet have a £2 billion shortfall. Local councils will have lost nearly 80 per cent in direct funding by 2020.
In reality, across the country this means women’s refuges closing, youth centres closing, libraries closing, museums closing.
But compassion can cost very little and just £10 million is needed to establish the child funeral fund campaigned for by my hon friend for Swansea East, Carolyn Harris.
Under this government there are 20,000 fewer police officers. And another 6,000 community support officers, and 11,000 Fire Service staff have been cut too.
Our communities cannot be kept safe on the cheap.
Tammy explains how this has affected her: “our police presence has been taken away meaning increasing crime. As a single parent I no longer feel safe in my own village, particularly after dark.”
Mr Deputy Speaker, five and a half million workers earn less than the living wage, a million more than just five years ago.
And the Chancellor can’t even see 1.4 million unemployed people.
There is a crisis of low pay and insecure work, affecting 1 in 4 women, and 1 in 6 men, a record 7.4 million people in working households in poverty.
If we want workers earning better pay, less dependent on in-work benefits, we need to strengthen trade unions. the most effective means to boost workers’ pay.
Instead this government weakened trade unions and introduced Employment Tribunal fees – now scrapped thanks to Unison’s legal victory.
And Mr Deputy Speaker, why didn’t the Chancellor take the opportunity to make two changes to control debt?
Firstly, to cap credit card debt so that nobody pays back more than they borrowed.
And secondly, to stop credit card companies increasing people’s credit limit without their say so.
Debt is being racked up because this government is weak on those who exploit people: the rail companies hiking fares above inflation year-on-year, the water companies and the energy suppliers.
During the general election it promised an energy cap that would benefit “around 17 million families on standard variable tariffs”. But every bill tells millions of families the government has broken its promise.
And with £10 billion in housing benefit going into the pockets of private landlords every year, housing is a key factor in driving up the welfare bill.
With this government delivering the worst rate of housebuilding since the 1920s and a quarter of a million fewer council homes, any commitment is welcome.
But we’ve been here before. The government promised 200,000 starter homes three years ago and not a single one has been built.
We need a large scale public house building programme, not this government’s accounting tricks and empty promises.
We back the abolition of stamp duty for first-time buyers because it was another Labour policy at the election, not a Tory one.
It’s this government’s continual preference for spin over substance that means, across this country, the words “Northern Powerhouse” and “Midlands Engine” are now met with derision.
Yorkshire and Humber gets only one-tenth of the transport investment per head given to London.
And government figures show that every region in the north of England has seen a fall in spending on services since 2012.
The Midlands, East and West, is receiving less than 8 per cent of total transport infrastructure investment, compared with over 50 per cent going to London.
In the East and West Midlands 1 in 4 workers are paid less than the living wage. So much for the ‘Midlands Engine’.
Re-announced funding for the Transpennine rail route won’t cut it and today’s other announcements won’t redress the balance.
Combined with counterproductive austerity, this lack of investment has consequences in sluggish growth and shrinking pay packets, and public investment has virtually halved.
Under this government, the UK has the lowest rate of public investment in the G7, but it is now investing in driverless cars after months of road-testing back seat driving in government.
By moving from RPI to CPI indexation on business rates the Chancellor has adopted another Labour policy, but why don’t they go further and adopt Labour’s entire business rates pledges including exempting plant and machinery and annual revaluation of business rates.
Nowhere has that been more evident than over Brexit.
Following round after round of fruitless Brexit negotiations the Brexit Secretary has been shunted out for the Prime Minister who has got no further.
Every major business organisation has written to the government telling them to pull their finger out.
Businesses are delaying investment decisions, but if this government doesn’t get its act together soon they will be taking relocation decisions.
Crashing out with ‘No deal’ and turning Britain into a tin-pot tax haven will damage people’s jobs and living standards, serving only a wealthy few.
It’s not as if this government isn’t doing its best to protect tax havens and their clients in the meantime.
The Paradise papers have again exposed how a super-rich elite is allowed to get away with dodging taxes.
This government has opposed measure after measure in this House, and in the European Parliament, to clamp down on the tax havens that facilitate this outrageous leaching from the public purse.
Mr Deputy Speaker, too often it feels like there is one rule for the super-rich and another for the rest of us.
The horrors of Grenfell Tower were a reflection of a system that puts profits before people, that fails to listen to working class people.
In 2013 this government received advice in a coroner’s report that sprinklers should be fitted in all high rise buildings.
Today this government failed to fund the £1 billion investment needed to make homes safe. The Chancellor says councils should contact them, but Nottingham has, Westminster has, and they’ve been refused!
In a Parliament building scheduled to be retrofitted with sprinklers, to protect us, the message from this government to people living in high rise homes is: You matter less.
Our country is marked by growing inequality and injustice.
We were promised a revolutionary Budget. The reality is nothing has changed.
People were looking for help from this Budget, they have been let down.
Let down by a government that like the economy they’ve presided over is weak and unstable and in need of urgent change.
They call this Budget, ‘Fit for the Future’. The reality is this is a government no longer fit for office.
I don’t make any money from my work. But you can support Politics and Insights and contribute by making a donation which will help me continue to research and write informative, insightful and independent articles, and to provide support to others. The smallest amount is much appreciated, and helps to keep my articles free and accessible to all – thank you.