This is an excellent article by Jack Monroe
An article in the Guardian recently claimed that ‘austerity has been hijacked by the moralisers’ – and judging by George Osborne’s latest announcement that “austerity works”, it seems they were right. As though it’s all just ‘cosy frugality’, as though we are all just living in a snapshot of a nostalgic poster of post-war Britain. I’m surprised the posters haven’t made a reappearance, unaltered, to back up the chancellors claims.
Eat less bread. Food is a weapon. Your own vegetables all year round. Dig for victory. Home grown food. Make do and mend. Keep calm and carry on.
But there’s nothing cosy and nostalgic about missing days of meals, turning the heating off for two consecutive winters and every bloody day and night in between.
There’s nothing cosy and nostalgic about unscrewing the light bulbs so you can’t accidentally turn them on, or selling your son’s shoes, or drinking the formula milk that the food bank gave you because there’s nothing else. If that’s cosy frugality, the moralisers and apologisers ought to try it. For a month. Or six. Or 18.
Turn off the fridge, because it’s empty anyway. Sell anything you can see lying around that you might get more than a quid for. Walk everywhere in the pouring rain, in your only pair of shoes, with a soaking wet and sobbing toddler old trailing behind you. Drag that toddler into every pub and shop in unreasonable walking distance and ask them if they have any job vacancies. Try not to go red as the girl behind the counter appraises your tatty jumper and dirty jeans before telling you that they have no jobs available. “For you”, you add in your head, and you drag that toddler home, still soaking, still unemployed, to not-quite dry out in your freezing cold flat.
Put two jumpers on that you’ll wear all week, to keep washing to a minimum. You sit at home in your coat anyway, and nobody’s there to notice.
Drag yourself to the cooker to pour some tinned tomatoes over some cold pasta, and try not to hurl it across the room in frustration when your toddler tells you he doesn’t want it: “I want something else, Mummy.” But there isn’t anything else. But aren’t we supposed to just keep calm and carry on?
You get up the next morning and give your child one of the last Weetabix, mashed with a little water, with a glass of tap water to wash it down with.
“Where’s mummy’s breakfast?” He asks, all big blue eyes and innocent concern. You tell him you aren’t hungry, but you weren’t hungry last night either, and sooner or later he’ll notice that mummy never seems hungry any more.
Hunger hurts. Hunger distresses, and depresses. Admitting that you cannot afford to feed your child is both terrifying and humiliating. Professionals that signpost people to food banks for help often report that they are reluctant to go, because it feels like begging. And my god, it feels like begging.
And you think if you admit to skipping meals, to feeding your child the same cold pasta for nights on end, you think if anyone notices the badly damaged wrists from your recent suicide attempt, that you might lose your son. He might be taken into care. And despite the cold and the despair and the mind raging with doubt and fear and uselessness, there’s a little boy that relies on you to provide his meals – no matter how rubbish they are – and to put his jumper on before he goes to bed at night. So you say you’re fine. But you’re not. You’re full of rain and heartache and anger and it’s starting to seep through the cracks in the kept up appearances. But don’t you just keep calm, and carry on?
My circumstances were not unique to me. The Oxfam report – Walking The Breadline, published in June this year, states that half a million people in the UK rely on food banks. Yet the Government puts their fingers in their ears, blaming feckless parenting and scroungers. Half a million feckless parents. Half a million scroungers. They claim that there is no link between cuts to welfare and the growing demand for food banks.
Lord Freud claims that people ‘turn up for free food’ – painting a picture of people waltzing in and topping up the Ocado delivery with a few battered fruits and some dented tins of tomatoes. Such comments display a complete disconnect from reality. You can’t just ‘turn up’ to a food bank. You need to be referred – by a childcare professional, a health visitor, social services or similar agency. Someone needs to recognise that your household is at serious risk of going hungry if they don’t intervene. And intervention is a feared word. So people become adept at pretending they don’t need help.
Michael Gove blames child poverty and hunger on reckless parenting – with no acknowledgement to the fact that many people using food banks are doing so because of benefit delays, sanctions, low income, and unemployment. No acknowledgement that many people who use food banks are IN WORK. What sort of a society do we live in where people who go out to work to support their families, need emergency food handouts?
Many parents tell of going to bed hungry themselves in order to feed their children. Gove would call that reckless parenting. And they repeat, they bleat, that food bank use has nothing to do with welfare cuts.
So here’s a figure.:
Since April 2013, and the introduction of the Bedroom Tax, food bank use in the UK has increased 175%.
The number one reason cited for food bank referral is cuts or delays to benefits, including sanctions and Bedroom Tax.
And while food banks are meeting a real and desperate need for half a million families in the UK, surely the responsibility for feeding the poorest and most vulnerable lies with the Government, not with charity? Isn’t that the entire point of the welfare state?
So in terms of feckless parenting, it is the state that is sending its children to school, to bed and to work hungry.
By cutting welfare lifelines, the state is the abusive parent.
By casting around to blame anyone else, by ignoring the cold hard face of true poverty in the UK, it is the state that is feckless.
By refusing to tackle poverty at its root, it is the government that is being neglectful.
But until they change housing benefit to monthly payments in line with people’s rent and mortgage payments, until they commit to a living wage legislation that is not age discriminatory, until they reinstate the crisis loan, revoke the bedroom tax – we need to carry on talking about it. Get angry. Get noisy. Use the collective voice of 6million union members to lobby and campaign and not stop until children are not going to bed hungry any more.
As Desmond Tutu said – there comes a point where we need to stop just pulling people out of the river. We need to go upstream and find out why they’re falling in.
Jack Monroe at the TUC, 9th September 2013.
The Poverty of Responsibility and the Politics of Blame
Quantitative Data on Poverty from the Joseph Rowntree Foundation.
According the the Tories, economic terrorism is the new humanism.
Poverty and Patrimony – the Evil Legacy of the Tories.
Thanks to Robert Livingstone for his brilliant art work
13 thoughts on “The Government Are Feckless, Neglectful and Abusive – My Speech at the TUC 2013 – Jack Monroe”
written brilliantly and true to the point . They think they screw people into the floor but do you no what some of those screws are bent and they will never screw us again after 2015
Reblogged this on Vox Political.
LikeLiked by 1 person
“Lord Freud claims that people ‘turn up for free food’ – painting a picture of people waltzing in and topping up the Ocado delivery ” Indeed. What’s more disturbing is he’s allowed to get away with this nonsense in the House of Lords. He ought to be booted out of the place for trying it on like this. Instead, his gilded existence continues undisturbed. I do believe we need a new system. Our Parliamentarians are no good to us.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Actually he was challenged well. In fact have a read on Hansard, at the debate regarding the Lobbying Bill, a good example of where there has been an outstanding challenge from Labour. Won’t make any difference – we have an authoritarian Government that has destroyed parliamentary democratic processes and safeguards.
Remember the welfare “reforms” that were hammered through the legislative process, despite opposition from Labour, and the House of Lords? “Financial privilege” was used to silence the critics and protesters. It wasn’t a one-off stunt.
Reblogged this on kickingthecat.
LikeLiked by 1 person
the only ones turning up for free food are those tapping scrounging bloodsucking parasitic leeches called the government! Funny how all the front bench seem to have piled on the pounds unlike Joe & Josephine Bloggs who lose twice as much weight through worry and stress!!!!
Im actually crying at this speech it so right ……
LikeLiked by 1 person
Reblogged at SMILING CARCASS’S TWO-PENNETH
Reblogged this on HUMAN RIGHTS & POLITICAL JOURNAL.
LikeLiked by 1 person
My grandmother died from malnutrition in Birmingham in 1932. Nice to see a return to the “good old days”.