A Conservative MP defends Jeremy Corbyn as he responds to Conservative’s dead cat strategy – allegations of ‘sexism’

Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn was accused of calling Prime Minister Theresa May a “stupid woman” in parliament today. 

Corbyn was seen after the alleged event on parliamentary footage muttering after he sat down following an exchange with a particularly vindictive May at the weekly Prime Minister’s Questions session during which she peevishly mocked him for not calling a vote of confidence in the government, turning the debate quite literally into utterly disrespectful pantomime.

A number of Conservative MPs demanded that Speaker of the House John Bercow  intervened but he refused, stating that he hadn’t heard Corbyn utter the alleged phrase. That resulted in Conservative MP and Leader of the House Andrea Leadsom aggressively critcising Bercow, saying the speaker had not apologised for calling her a “stupid woman” earlier in the year. 

Some of the media claimed that ‘lip speakers’ said Corbyn had said “stupid woman”. The BBC said that this was unanimously agreed among lip readers. However it isn’t:

alison

Corbyn stated: “I referred to those who I believe were seeking to turn a debate about the national crisis facing our country into a pantomime as ‘stupid people’,’ he said. ‘I did not use the words ‘stupid woman’ about the Prime Minister or anyone else, and am completely opposed to the use of sexist or misogynist language in absolutely any form at all.”

It’s very true that the Conservatives, taking their cue from the prime minister, turned PMQs into an utterly disrespectful, diversionary and vindictive pantomime, complete with the usual spiteful smirks, and barn yard braying that the Conservatives have normalised in the Commons . You can see the clip of the pantomime here 

Professional lip readers have been divided on what they think he said.

Desmond Swayne MP

One Conservative MP, Desmond Swayne, has actually defended Corbyn, saying that condemning what an MP might have said under their breath is entering the “realms of thought crime”.

He said: “What unnerved me was the enthusiasm with which colleagues preyed-in-aid the skills of lip-readers to work out exactly what he said.

“I sometimes whisper things under my breath: They are my private thoughts, perhaps to be shared with a close neighbour only, that’s why I whisper them rather than stating them out loud for the record.

“The notion that we should be watched by lip-readers to see what we are whispering, so that we can be hauled before the authorities (in this case Mr Speaker), is deeply worrying.

“This is dangerous territory: we are on a slippery slope to the ‘thought crime’ of which George Orwell so eloquently warned in his novel 1984. We should make it compulsory New Year reading for all MPs.”

I thought the Conservatives were actually using 1984 as a manual.

Swayne is right. No-one in the media seems worried that a man mumbling something  to himself that no-one actually heard warrants the authoritarian response of employing lip readers to police the thoughts and quiet mutterings of the leader of the opposition. The abuse and rudeness he has to confront day after day in the Commons is conveniently ignored, of course. Shame on the majority of mainstream media outlets for printing from the Tory PR crib sheet without question.

Around 200 Tory MPs clamoured to make a point of order, amid howls of outrage and shrieked demands for an apology.

It’s extraordinary that the government have become the first in the UK to be found in contempt of parliament, they have systematically avoided accountability, they have conducted Commons debates behaving disruptively, maliciously, without decorum, showing the utmost disrespect towards opposition parties and the general public. 

The Labour leader’s spokesman had said afterwards that Corbyn had said ‘stupid people’, referring generally to Conservative MPs who were not taking the issues being debated seriously. That’s an understatement, the Conservatives were behaving as they usually do, as vindictive, baying barn yard bullies.

He said he had confirmed the word spoken with the Labour leader personally, adding: “He did not call her a stupid woman and so I don’t think there’s any basis for an apology.” before adding the following insightful words: “Anyone interested in the crisis facing the country?”

It’s a dead cat

Dead cat strategy refers to the introduction of a dramatic, shocking, or sensationalist topic to divert discourse away from a more damaging topic. Not to be confused with Wag the Dog, which is a 1997 black comedy film where a spin doctor and a Hollywood producer fabricate a war to distract voters from a presidential sex scandal. It was produced and directed by Barry Levinson. Wag the Dog was released one month before the outbreak of the Lewinsky scandal and the subsequent bombing of the Al-Shifa pharmaceutical factory in Sudan by the Clinton administration in August 1998, which prompted the media to draw comparisons between the film and reality. The comparison was made again in December 1998 when the administration initiated a bombing campaign of Iraq just prior to Clinton’s impeachment over the Lewinsky scandal.

Diversionary strategies are just what the term implies: tactics used to try to derail and silence an argument rather than address it. It’s a somewhat overused strategy by the Tories, it typically involves diverting the discussion by attempting to aggressively shame an opponent or critic complete with complicit crib sheeted multiple media echoes and variations of “Shame on you”. 

Raise the issue of racism, and the Conservatives will call you racist. Highlight some example of bullying and you are ‘the real bully’. Express concern about low wages for the working majority and you are accused of waging ‘class warfare’. Black is white, up is down, and nowhere does this actually make sense.

The Conservatives have become masters of public spin campaigns to distract or neutralise legitimate debate about issues.

 


I don’t make any money from my work. I am disabled because of illness and often struggle to get by. If you want to, you can help by making a donation to help me continue to research and write informative, insightful and independent articles, and to provide support to others.

DonatenowButton

15 thoughts on “A Conservative MP defends Jeremy Corbyn as he responds to Conservative’s dead cat strategy – allegations of ‘sexism’

  1. After watching debates in the House of Commons both yesterday and today it is pretty obvious that there has been a significant shift in Tory tactics. They have obviously decided to add winding-up the opposition parties by being obviously disrespectful as well as repeatedly mis-representing what opposition MPs have said to their serial abuses of parliamentary procedures.The Tories are taking the piss.

    We really do have a right to expect much better from our elected representatives. The Tories are underming our democracratic processes.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. They’re all brilliant lip readers one would believe – otherwise – gosh they so hate Mr Corbyn don’t they as to slap some unsubstantiated calumny upon him?

    Say ‘woman’ and the mouth needs to pucker up closing lips into a kiss-like shape. Say ‘people’ and the lips flatten with a slight opening and with corners of mouth pushed away stretching mouth and keeping mouth pretty much closed. Corbyn’s mouth did NOT pucker as far as I can tell from the video evidence. My view is that, with pause while the Tory baying was loud, Corbyn reacted ‘silently’ to himself in response to baying ‘people’ in the House. He told the truth when called back to the House to explain himself to all those out of control raucous Tory turkeys.

    Talk Radio does an extremely good analysis of the event https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eQIL32OcK1s

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Reblogged this on Worldtruth and commented:
    Why, apart from the obvious “dead cat” ploy, would the Tories misreprepresent Corbyn’s muttering of “Stupid People”(which can be clearly seen if you read lips as I do)when it will be so easily shown for the false accusation it was? Stupid People.

    Like

  4. If Corbyn did say. Stupid woman well I don’t think anyone would pretend may isn’t a woman so clearly that part can’t be an insult, Stupid well maybe if you only consider her idea of denying democracy, but personally I would say devious. The misdirection is something the tories are very good at, like Cameron’s endless “for hard working people” mantra very good some say, but not if you are disabled incapacitated sick or otherwise unable to work, because it clearly means you are discriminated against. His damage will take at least a generation to repair.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. Hats off to the Conservative MP, Desmond Swayne, for telling it like it is. I wonder for how many others, like myself, the first response on hearing the reports of this nonsense was to mutter (under our breaths of course) “Well, she IS a stupid woman!”.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. I was watching live on this occasion and what surprised me was that the comments that come-up on the right hand of the screen immediately said that Corby said “stupid woman”. I asked my wife how they could do it so quickly – it was almost too quick to be true.

    Like

  7. Am not surprised as usual the Tories use their pathetic lies to try and destroy Jeremy Corbyn, because the Jeremy Corbyn is mature as well as civilised and he supports women in his party and in society.

    Maggie May is an asshole and that’s a fact. The Tories are so vile, dishonest and childish that they want to be heard.

    Maggie May shamefully was supporting one of her MPs who has been investigated for sexual harassment. You look at the hypocrisy of the Tories and apart from that they’ve been getting away with their sexual remarks against non Tory women especially in our Labour Party.

    Like

  8. Further (and I would argue conclusive) audio and video evidence that Jeremy is telling the truth.

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s